PROJECT ECHO
Bore sight Cameras
By K. L. WARTHMAN
(Manuscript received April 7, 1961)
Motion picture cameras equipped with telephoto lenses were installed on
the Project Echo transmitting and receiving antennas located at Holmdel,
New Jersey. When the Echo satellite was visible, a camera obtained a
photographic record of the pointing accuracy of the antenna. These data
were then used to correlate variations of signal strength with deviations in an-
tenna pointing angle.
I. INTRODUCTION
The conventional method of evaluating the tracking performance of
radar antennas has been to provide a camera-lens system mounted on
the antenna structure to provide an optical line-of-sight parallel to the
radar beam. This permits the recording on motion picture film of the
radar pointing error, whenever the object being tracked is capable of
being photographed. Camera instrumentation of this type was provided
for both Holmdel antennas, the 60-foot paraboloid transmitter and the
20-foot horn receiver.*
II. PHOTOGRAPHIC CONSIDERATIONS
The brightness of the Echo satellite was expected to be greater than
that of a first-magnitude star. Experience in astronomical photography
indicated that first-magnitude stars could be recorded on Tri-X negative
film (Eastman Kodak No. 7233) with an exposure of jfo second and
a lens aperture of f3.5. Accordingly, it was decided to use a camera speed
of four frames per second. This frame rate provides an exposure time of
£ second and at the same time affords 16 minutes of continuous camera
* Although this equipment was designed by the Bell System as part of its re-
search and development program, it was operated in connection with Project
Echo under Contract NASW-110 for the National Aeronautics and Space Adminis-
tration.
1227
1228 THE BELL SYSTEM TECHNICAL JOURNAL, JULY 1961
Fig. 1 — Tracking camera.
Fig. 2 — Synchronous motor with gear reductions for 24, 8. 4 frames per second.
BORESIGHT CAMERAS
1229
m
^i:--YvEM .1
C
° i
1230
THE BELL SYSTEM TECHNICAL JOURNAL, JULY 1961
operation with the 100-foot film capacity of the camera. The 16-mm
film was considered adequate for the photographic detail required and
was selected in preference to 35-mm film in order to minimize film costs,
processing charges, storage space, and equipment investment.
III. CAMERA
The Arriflex 16-mm camera (see Fig. 1) was selected for Project Echo
because the feature of through-the-lens viewing was desired for align-
ment of the optical system with the transmitting and receiving antennas.
Also, this camera could have been equipped with a 400-foot magazine if
a faster frame rate or longer tracking time had been desired. A 24-frame-
per-second synchronous motor was ordered with special gear reductions
that could be easily interchanged to provide four or eight frames per
second (see Fig. 2).
IV. LENS
The desired field of view of 3 degrees was obtained by using a 150-mm,
f3.5 Kilfitt lens. This field of view was large enough to keep the satellite
i. "
Fig. 4 — Camera mounted on horn receiver.
BORESICHT CAMERAS
1231
image within the film frame during early tests when some tracking diffi-
culties could be expected. The 150-mm lens gave enough magnification
to permit reducing the data to the desired accuracy. The camera system
was designed so that a 300-mm lens could be used without modification
if desired in later tests.
V. RETICLE AND TIMING MARKS
A projected reticle was imaged on the film by using a beam splitter.
The optical schematic is shown in Fig. 3. The time in seconds was re-
corded on the film by using a conventional telephone message register
as a stepping counter. The reticle and message register were also visible
through the eyepiece for optical alignment and time correlation. The
necessary optics to project these images on the film were assembled in a
housing which replaced the standard lens-to-camera adaptor.
Fig. 5 — Camera mounted ou paraboloid transmitter.
1232
THE BELL SYSTEM TECHNICAL JOURNAL, JULY 1961
VI. CAMERA MOUNTING
The cameras were mounted on the vertical center-line and just beyond
the lower edge of the antenna apertures (Figs. 4 and 5). This location
placed the cameras about 8 feet above ground level when the antennas
were pointed at the horizon so that they could be loaded and checked for
alignment from a small platform. A special dovetailed mount was pro-
Fig. 6 — Typical single 16-mm frame (pass 70, August 18, 1960).
BORESICHT CAMERAS 1233
vided for the cameras to permit removal and replacement without dis-
turbing the alignment. The base of this special mount was equipped with
adjustments for alignment in elevation and azimuth. A weatherproof
cover with a front opening was provided in the event that inclement
weather was experienced during operation.
VII. POWER SUPPLY AND CAMERA CONTROL
Special 42-volt power supplies were used to operate the synchronous
camera drive motors. These power supplies were mounted on the anten-
nas adjacent to the cameras. The cameras could be operated at the an-
tennas to facilitate loading of film and alignment, or could be operated
remotely from the main control console.
VIII. RESULTS
The enlarged view of a single 16-mm frame of pass 70 .shows the Echo
satellite in the reticle opening (Fig. 6). The reticle opening is 0.15 de-
gree, which is slightly less than the original design of J degree. The letter
h at the end of the message register number indicates that the film came
from the camera mounted on the horn antenna. From August 12, 19(50,
to March 15, 1961, 6900 feet of film were exposed during 39 Echo satel-
lite passes.